Settlers Inn started in 1993 by Tom and Joan Dorsey. Tom, a manufacturing engineer , and Joan a registered dietitian, wanted to provide a place for high quality, nutritious, home cooking. They first opened as a full service restaurant and tavern in a renovated historic building in downtown Cedarburg.

As the demand for their food increased they expanded to include catering. One year later a deli and bakery were added. We are a family owned and operated business. We are a part of the community having raised our three children in Cedarburg. All our children and Tom’s parents have worked in the business over the years.


Settlers Inn - The Place For All Your Food Needs

Have lunch in our 125 year old historic dining room complete with original woodwork, bar, icebox, and tin ceiling. Dining room available for rental for your private party. read more

Carryout entrees, sandwiches, soups, salads and desserts are available daily. Make dinner more enjoyable with meal selections from our freezer. read more

Enjoy from scratch baking specializing in home style pies, cakes and cupcakes, cut out sugar cookies, and dessert more

Whether it be corporate or personal, ala carte or full service, let Settlers Inn make your special events fun, easy, and more


Monday-Thursday 9am-5:30pm
Friday 9am-7pm
Saturday 9am-3pm

Available seven days a week with advance notice

Restaurant Home Deli Bakery Catering Specials